top of page
Search

God, Why Did You Let Me Love Something I Was Going to Lose?

Aug 15
8 min read

I've asked God this question more times than I can count.

God, why did You let me love something You knew I was going to lose?

Why let my heart become attached? Why let me dream? Why let me imagine birthdays, Christmas mornings, ordinary Tuesdays, family pictures, bedtime routines, first days of school, and all the little moments in between if You already knew I wouldn't get to have them?

I've asked that question about my babies.

And years later, I found myself asking it about another child who wasn't born from my body, but somehow still found a place in my heart.

The Babies I Never Got to Watch Grow

Gabriel and Isabella made me a mother before I ever got the chance to experience motherhood the way I imagined it.

I loved them before I knew who they would become.

I imagined their faces. Their personalities. Their little voices. What they would look like running through my house. What birthdays would look like. What kind of mother I would be to them.

I didn't need years of memories to love them.

They were mine, and that was enough.

And then I lost them.

Pregnancy loss is such a complicated kind of grief because you're not only grieving the baby you lost. You're grieving everything that baby represented.

You're grieving first steps that will never happen.

First words you'll never hear.

Birthdays you'll never plan.

Pictures you'll never take.

Christmas mornings you'll never wake up to.

You're grieving an entire lifetime of memories you somehow already loved even though you never got the chance to make them.

And I think that's one of the hardest parts of losing a baby.

You aren't only burying what was.

You're grieving everything that was supposed to be.

For a long time, I couldn't understand why God would allow me to love my babies so deeply if He knew I wouldn't get to watch them grow.

Why allow motherhood to awaken inside of me just to leave my arms empty?

Why let me dream about a future He already knew would look completely different?

I still don't have a perfect answer for that.

And maybe I never will.

But then life taught me there was another kind of grief I didn't know existed.

Then I Loved Another Little Boy

Years later, I entered a relationship with someone who had a son.

And somewhere along the way, loving his dad meant loving him too.

It happened in the ordinary moments.

Reading bedtime stories.

Taking care of him when he was sick.

Going to the park.

Playing together.

Being there for the little routines that probably looked insignificant to everyone else but became incredibly meaningful to me.

He didn't come from my body.

He wasn't mine.

I knew that.

But my heart still learned how to love him.

And maybe because of everything I had already experienced, loving and caring for a child awakened something inside of me that I had missed more than I realized.

I got to nurture again.

I got to protect.

I got to comfort.

I got to experience little pieces of everyday life with a child.

For a season, I was allowed to exist in a version of myself that felt incredibly natural to me.

And then the relationship ended.

I knew breakups meant losing the person you were dating.

What I wasn't prepared for was realizing that sometimes a breakup takes other people with it.

And suddenly, I was grieving another child.

Not from my body this time.

And not because he died.

He was still here.

That was what made this grief so confusing.

There was no funeral.

There was no official goodbye.

There wasn't necessarily a word for what I was experiencing.

Because how do you explain that you're grieving someone who is still alive?

He's still somewhere growing.

Still laughing.

Still learning.

Still having birthdays.

Still becoming more and more of the person God created him to be.

And I have to love him without getting to witness it.

There is something incredibly painful about knowing someone you love still exists in this world while accepting that you may no longer have a place in theirs.

And once again, I found myself asking God:

Why did You let me love him if You knew I wasn't going to get to keep him in my life?

Sometimes We Lose Versions of Ourselves Too

Eventually I realized there was another layer underneath all of this grief.

I wasn't only grieving the people I lost.

I was grieving who I was allowed to be while I had them.

When I lost Gabriel, I didn't only grieve Gabriel.

I grieved the version of me who thought she was going to raise him.

When I lost Isabella, I didn't only grieve Isabella.

I grieved the version of me who imagined another future with another baby I loved.

I grieved the mother I thought I was going to become.

The birthdays I thought I would celebrate.

The little voices I thought would call for me.

The milestones I thought I would photograph.

The home I imagined them running through.

I lost entire versions of my future when I lost them.

And years later, through that breakup, I lost another version of myself.

The version who got to care for a little boy.

The version who read the bedtime stories.

The version who took care of him when he wasn't feeling well.

The version who had a place in his little world.

One day I was allowed to be that person.

And then suddenly, I wasn't.

Maybe that's why some losses feel so much bigger than the person we're missing.

Because sometimes we're grieving an entire world that existed around them.

The routines.

The plans.

The identity.

The future.

The traditions that hadn't even become traditions yet.

The version of ourselves that only existed because they were there.

And that led me to another question for God:

Why did You let me become her if You knew I wouldn't get to stay her?

Maybe I Didn't Stop Being Her

That's the part I'm beginning to see differently.

Maybe I didn't stop being her.

Maybe those versions of myself weren't completely taken away when the people attached to them were.

Because losing them took so much from me, but it couldn't take away everything they gave me.

Gabriel and Isabella taught me that motherhood can begin long before you ever hold your baby in your arms.

They taught me that love doesn't require years of memories to be real.

I loved them because they were mine.

I dreamed for them.

I imagined them growing.

And when they died, that love didn't die with them.

Their lives changed the way I see grief.

They changed the way I see mothers with empty arms.

They gave me a tenderness toward hurting people that I don't know if I would have otherwise.

So much of what I pour into other people today came from places in me that once completely broke.

And then another little boy taught me something different.

He showed me that my capacity to love a child wasn't limited to a child who came from my own body.

I could nurture.

I could protect.

I could comfort.

I could love the ordinary moments.

I could care deeply for a child without needing him to belong to me first.

The breakup could take away my role in his life.

But it couldn't take away what loving him revealed about my heart.

I am still nurturing.

I am still maternal.

I am still someone who loves children deeply.

I am still someone who notices the grieving mother because I understand what it feels like to have dreams of motherhood suddenly look completely different.

I am still someone who understands that a child's importance isn't measured by how long they lived or whether we share DNA.

And maybe most importantly, I am still capable of loving even after learning how badly love can hurt when someone is gone.

So What Did Loving Them Leave Behind?

Maybe that's the question I've been missing.

Instead of only asking:

God, why did You let me love them if I was going to lose them?

Maybe I also need to ask:

What did loving them leave inside of me that losing them couldn't take away?

Because grief took a lot.

It took people.

It took plans.

It took imagined futures.

It took roles I desperately wanted to keep.

It took versions of my life I thought I was going to live.

But grief couldn't take the tenderness they gave me.

It couldn't take the compassion.

It couldn't take the memories.

It couldn't take the mothering heart they awakened.

It couldn't take the ways their lives changed mine.

And it couldn't make me regret loving them.

Maybe God's purpose isn't hidden somewhere in why I lost them.

Maybe some of the purpose can be found in who I became because I loved them.

That doesn't make the losses hurt less.

It doesn't make me thankful that I lost them.

And it doesn't mean I suddenly understand why God allowed any of it.

There are still questions I don't have answers to.

There are still things I wish God had written differently.

There are still moments when I would choose having them here over every lesson grief has ever taught me.

But maybe faith isn't pretending I understand.

Maybe faith is being willing to tell God, "I don't understand why You allowed this, but I still trust that the love wasn't wasted."

Psalm 34:18 says:

"The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit."

It doesn't say we won't become brokenhearted.

It doesn't say everyone we love will stay.

It doesn't promise that every story will end the way we prayed it would.

It tells us where God will be when our hearts break.

Close.

And maybe that's what I'm learning.

God was close when I lost Gabriel.

God was close when I lost Isabella.

God was close when another kind of goodbye broke my heart years later.

And God is still close while I figure out what to do with all the love that had nowhere to go.

Loving Them Wasn't a Mistake

Maybe I'll always have moments when I ask God why He allowed me to love people He knew I wouldn't get to keep.

But I'm beginning to realize that keeping someone isn't the only evidence that loving them had a purpose.

Some people stay in our lives.

Some people leave.

Some people are only here for a heartbreakingly short time.

And sometimes someone can still be alive while becoming someone we have to learn to love from a distance.

But their absence doesn't erase their impact.

Gabriel mattered.

Isabella mattered.

That little boy matters.

And the love I had for each of them mattered.

I don't have to erase that love in order to heal.

I don't have to pretend they weren't important so moving forward becomes easier.

And I don't have to regret becoming the version of myself who loved them just because I didn't get to remain in the life I imagined.

Because maybe I was wrong when I thought I lost every version of myself that existed with them.

She's still here.

The mother who loved Gabriel is still here.

The mother who loved Isabella is still here.

The woman who discovered she could deeply love a child she didn't give birth to is still here.

The caretaker is still here.

The tenderness is still here.

The compassion is still here.

The love is still here.

They are all still pieces of me.

So maybe the answer to "God, why did You let me love something I was going to lose?" isn't an explanation for why I lost them.

Maybe, for now, the answer is simply recognizing what loving them did to me.

They taught me how to love in a way that loss couldn't teach me how to stop.

And maybe something doesn't have to last forever for the love inside of it to have been real.

“He has made everything beautiful in its time.” Ecclesiastes 3:11

 
 
 

Comments


IMG_8754_edited_edited_edited.jpg

Hi, thanks for stopping by!

Hi, thanks for stopping by. This space holds pieces of my heart — the lessons I’m learning in real time, the seasons I’m walking through, and the quiet ways God is shaping me. I don’t have it all figured out, but I’m committed to growing out loud. If that resonates with you, stay awhile.

Let the posts come to you.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest

Share Your Thoughts with Me

© 2026 by By Daniela Derivet. All rights reserved.

bottom of page